Former Pentagon official Michael Rubin has issued a sharp criticism of Pakistan’s Army Chief, General Asim Munir, drawing a comparison to Al Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden. The remarks were made in response to Munir’s recent nuclear threats during his visit to the United States. Rubin labeled Pakistan’s conduct as symptomatic of a “chaotic nation,” accusing it of engaging in war-like rhetoric. He further compared Munir’s statements to the extremist ideology of the Islamic State, thus linking him to bin Laden, the figure behind the 9/11 attacks. The controversy arose from Munir’s alleged warning that Pakistan would take half the world down with it if it collapsed. This statement was purportedly made during a meeting in Tampa, Florida, attended by US military officials. India has also voiced criticism of the nuclear attack threat, calling the language coming from a friendly nation unfortunate. Rubin, in an interview with news agency ANI, stated that such threats made on American soil are completely unacceptable and could lead to the misuse of nuclear weapons by extremist groups. He emphasized that Pakistan’s problems are more challenging than conventional diplomatic problems. “Americans usually look at terrorism with a view of complaint or pain, but they do not understand the ideology of terrorists. Asim Munir is Osama bin Laden wearing a suit,” he said. Rubin’s statements raised questions regarding Pakistan’s state responsibilities. He suggested a “controlled disintegration” of Pakistan, including support for regions like Balochistan. He also expressed the need for potential military intervention to safeguard Pakistan’s nuclear weapons. He advocated for the removal of Pakistan’s status as a “Major Non-NATO Ally” and called for Asim Munir to be declared persona non grata in the US, suggesting a ban on any future US visas. He added that a US entry ban should remain until Pakistan clarifies its position and offers an apology.
